1874-75 – Westonbirt Manor, Tetbury, Gloucestershire

SM 21 – Feb 13

Westonbirt Manor, in Tetbury, Gloucestershire, was originally owned and developed by the Holford family, who lived there from 1685.[i]   Robert Holford (1808-92) was lucky, as well as being hard working and very astute.   He inherited the 1,000-acre estate from his father; was left £1 million on the death of a bachelor uncle; worked as a successful legal practitioner in London, and bought a large stake in the newly formed New River Company of Stoke Newington.         Between 1864 and 1872, he commissioned Lewis Vulliamy to build him a new Elizabethan palace to replace the old manor house at Westonbirt, and he even moved the village half a mile down the road in order not to spoil his sight lines.[ii]

  5-1-21-01 - Westonbirt School 1

 Fig 1  –  Westonbirt Manor in spring

 His great love was the planting of trees, and he began work on developing the Westonbirt Arboretum – which is now separated from the main house – when he was only twenty-one years of age.   He also made extensive alterations to the gardens surrounding the house, where the soil is light and stony, and eminently suitable for the growth of pines and other evergreens, for which he had a particular passion.

The gardens immediately surrounding the house total 40 acres, and Holford is thought to have designed these himself, although it is reputed that he drew much of his inspiration from the work of William Gilpin, a leading proponent of the ‘picturesque’ movement at that time.   This influence is reflected in the way in which the formal terraces and lawns immediately surrounding the house gradually give way to informal areas, with specimen trees artistically placed by Holford, both singly and in groups.

 5-1-21-02 - Westonbirt Rock Garden 3

 Fig 2  –  Through the pathway to the rock garden

To the south west of the house – in the area on which once stood the original village – there is a small artificial lake and a clearing in which stands a rockery and grotto.   These features were the work of James Pulham and Son during 1874-75, and the entry in his promotional booklet is characteristically brief:

‘Fernery, Alipnery and Lake concreted.’ [iii]

However, the booklet also contains an excerpt from a review published in the Journal of Horticulture and Cottage Gardener [iv] that says:

‘Some rockwork, executed by Mr. Pulham, of Broxbourne, next claims attention.   We have before had occasion to notice in connection with Battersea Park how well he executes this sort of work, which it must be confessed is one of the most difficult things to manage well in landscape gardening.   Where rocks naturally exist the utilisation of them for ornamental purposes can generally be effected with ease and without much expense – where nature does much, art is the less required – but the artificial arrangement of rocks in places where they do not naturally occur is more frequently bungled than anything we know.

‘The biggest mountain that man can make is but a molehill to the great upheavals of nature, nor would it be desirable, even if we could attain it, to form any approach to a natural hill in our gardens; but, on the other hand, more modest efforts are apt to result in miniature caves that no one can go into, masses of stones that a man and a barrow could take away in a few hours, and for which there is no raison d’etre in a cultivated place.   Mr. Pulham in this instance has made the rockwork so that it might be supposed to be the remains of the quarry from which the stones had been taken to build the house, and an excellent resemblance to a disused quarry the place bears.   ‘Made to puzzle the geologists of a future age,’ Mr. Lucas, Mr. Holford’s gardener, suggested; but geologists are a hard-headed, as well as hard-handed race, and are not so easily taken in.’

There was another article about these gardens published in Country Life some thirty years later.[v]   This is what it had to say:

‘Nature did not help much in this dry elevated land between 300ft and 400ft above the sea, for the ground was little diversified, and there was neither stream nor lake, nor any outcropping of picturesque rock such as now we behold.   Yet, where skill and knowledge direct operations to a definite end, marvels are wrought. . . There is fine terracing on the south front, and an Italian garden is on the east, with a sunken garden near it, while towards the west are the lake, rockeries, and glades in a style worthy of Repton. . .

5-1-21-03 - Westonbirt - E J - Dingle

 Fig 3  –  Picturesque rockeries and glades ’in a style worthy of Repton’   (Photo by E Johnson)

 ‘We may now notice that the lake is entirely artificial, though Nature herself could scarce excel the charm.   The rockwork was laid out about thirty years ago by Messrs Pulham, who are still, in that department of garden work, pre-eminent.   The rock crops out from the ground in the most natural way, perfectly stratified, and, where the village stood, a most charming part of the garden has been created.   The lake is not large, but it is so shaped that it is never all seen at once.   Its tasteful margins are most charming, the weather-stained rocks are overrun with an infinite variety of alpine plants and shrubs. . .’

Fig 2 shows the unobtrusive pathway that leads to the rock garden.   It is a typical Pulham device – simple outcrops of limestone rocks, with cement stratifications, leading the eye naturally into the glade where one can see further outcrops.   The visitor can only see one corner of it from here, though, and it is impossible to resist the temptation to walk through the path, and view the glade itself.

Fig 3 is taken from inside the glade, and shows a small grotto as the main feature of this section of the garden.   Here are the ‘remains of the small quarry’ referred to in the Journal of Horticulture article of 1875, and one can also see another facet of James 2’s work here – i.e., in the way that small rock outcrops rise out of the ground, and gradually get larger as they approach the central grotto feature.

Pulham also loved the sight and sound of flowing water, and nothing pleased him more than to create a rock feature in a quiet woodland spot, with a stream babbling quietly over rocky cascades through its centre.   There are thankfully still some remaining examples in good condition today, and they are indeed idyllic places to behold.

 5-1-21-04 - Westonbirt - E J - Lake 1

Fig 4  –  The lake edge at Westonbirt   (Photo by E Johnson)

 The small lake at Westonbirt is one such place.  As the 1905 article in Country Life points out, it is not possible to see the whole expanse of the lake from any one vantage point – the placement of the trees provides an irresistible invitation to walk all round the irregular perimeter in order to see what is ‘just around the next corner.’   Fig 4 shows one section of the bank, plus a small rocky island, whilst Fig 5 shows that the lake is obviously admired as much by the ducks as it is by the humans, and, on the far side from the house, there is a small waterfall to create the lovely, peaceful sound of water tumbling over rocks.

There is obviously far more to see that just the Pulham rockwork described here.   There is the spectacular Italian garden, designed by Vulliamy, for example, and the rare and interesting trees planted by Robert Holford – some of which still remain, having managed to survive the storms of recent years.   Trees like the magnificent magnolias and maples that provide glorious colour during the spring and autumn.   Those few remaining original trees are now living on borrowed time, of course, but the collection did not stop when Robert Holford died.   His son, later to become Sir George Holford, followed in his father’s footsteps, and added generously to the glorious array of exotic specimens.

5-1-21-05 - Westonbirt Waterfall 2

 Fig 5  –  The waterfall in the lake at Westonbirt

 Soon after Sir George’s death, the house and gardens were taken over by the Westonbirt Girls School, and, luckily, little has changed since that time, apart from the loss of those trees that were either felled by storms, or hit by disease.   Small wonder, then, that these gardens are now designated Grade I on the register of historic gardens.

While at Westonbirt, I also noticed three exceptionally fine plaster ceilings, and immediately wondered whether the Pulham team may have been responsible for them.   As far as is known, no records exist to substantiate this suggestion one way or the other, but, since they must have been done during the period when the ‘rock builders’ were at work in the grounds, there must be a possibility.   Figs 6 and 7 show the ceilings in the Library and the Dining Room.

5-1-21-06 - Westonbirt Ceiling 1

 Fig 6  –  Ornate ceiling of the Library at Westonbirt

 5-1-21-07 - Westonbirt Ceiling 3

 Fig 7  –  Dining Room ceiling at Westonbirt

[i]    ‘In Praise of the Other Westonbirt’ (Author unknown), Country Life, 20/27 December 2001

[ii]   Westonbirt Gardens by Michael Symes, published by the Dept of Extra-Mural Studies, University of London, 1988

[iii]    Picturesque Ferneries and Rock Garden Scenery, a promotional booklet written and published by James Pulham 2 c1877

[iv]    Journal of Horticulture and Cottage Gardener,  July 31st, 1875

[v]    Country Life, 25th March 1905`

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s